The other day I was traveling on Air China and received one of the most coveted things in all of air travel: a free upgrade known as an “op-up” (operational upgrade).
The other day, I tweeted about the great leg room in the exit row of Air China’s two-class intra-Asia planes. Hoping to get some nice leg room again, I decided to mix-up my request:
About eighty minutes prior to departure, ROB hands CHECK-IN AGENT at Pudong his passport and United 1K (Star Alliance Gold) card. CHECK-IN AGENT begins typing on keyboard like a broken piano and says in Chinese to a co-worker that she has to input ROB’s United Mileage Plus number.
ROB (nonchalantly): Do you have any business class seats available for purchase?
CHECK-IN AGENT: Sorry, we are all sold out.
ROB: Oh, what about exit row?
CHECK-IN AGENT (checking her computer): Yes, we have window.
ROB: I’ll take it.
Fast-forward to boarding time after most of the plane has boarded. ROB gets to the plane about 25 minutes prior to takeoff and when his boarding pass is scanned, the computer makes a beep. The GATE AGENT mutters something to his supervisor and they converse for a minute.
GATE AGENT: Sir, your seat has been changed. (He scribbles a new seat number on the boarding pass and presents it to ROB.)
Hoping for an op-op, ROB takes the his boarding pass . His previous intra-Asia flight on Air China was on a two-class Boeing 737 where any row beyond the second was economy. He notices “11L” written in blue pen on the pass and takes it. Meanwhile, several people in sports uniforms proceed onto the plane.
ROB: Thank you.
ROB walks to the plane and notices is is a larger, three-class Boeing 767-300. He hands his boarding pass to the FLIGHT ATTENDANT and she looks at it, puzzled at the handwritten annotation to the paper.
FLIGHT ATTENDANT: Please wait a moment.
Confused, the FLIGHT ATTENDANT talks to another crew member and then still without an answer, she exits the plane and returns to the gate. Ten minutes later, she returns.
FLIGHT ATTENDANT: Please take seat 11L sir, Business Class.
ROB: Thank you!
ROB sits down in business class, the only passenger who is not a member of Team China soccer.


The leg room was slightly less than the other business class seats due to the partition between business and first, but there was an interesting rubber footrest meant to make the seat more comfortable. For a flight only a little over two hours, we even got a full business class meal!




In general, most people I know, including business travelers, often book economy class for short-haul intra-Asia flights, similar to savvy travelers in North America and Europe who do the same for short haul flights. My personal rule of thumb is over/under four hours, and it was quite apparent on the plane as first class only had two passengers, one of which was a NRSA (non-revenue, space available) Air China employee. Having experienced Air China business class once, I’d definitely be happy to experience it again. (Author’s Note: I have previously experienced first-class on Air China before on a two-class short-haul intra-Asia flight, but this was my first business class experience.)