Jeff Smisek’s presentation yesterday at the 2011 Deutsche Bank Airline Equity Conference was a bit of a rehash of Sr. VP John Rainey’s presentation just last week, but he did speak to a couple of points I hadn’t heard before. First up, here are a few of those known items with the related slides (courtesy of United Airlines):
- Jeff highlighted that United has the world’s best network, leads the (domestic) competition in financial performance, is focused on return on invested capital (ROIC) and is either the number one or two carrier (in terms of available seat miles or ASMs) flying internationally from the U.S.

- As far as the capacity forecast for 2012, he’s claiming it will be flat overall by way of decreasing domestic (in part by adding Economy Plus to Continental’s fleet) and growing international (787 acquisitions and market-driven adjustments where appropriate).

- He highlighted the upcoming customer enhancements, namely refreshing the interiors of the Airbus fleet, adding Boeing 737-900ERs with the “Sky” interior, investing in better seats and completely overhauling the now tired premium service fleet that operates between JFK-SFO/LAX. For the last he reiterated the p.s. fleet would see Business flat-beds, Economy Plus and regular economy.

Now onto the newer items I hadn’t specifically heard yet this year:
- A portion of the compensation scheme for managers and above is dependent on the company’s ROIC and internal surveys from the work groups they manage. He specifically said 20% of their pay is based on the latter, but I’m sure it must be more of a bonus payout upon hitting certain scoring thresholds.
- The streaming Wi-Fi entertainment coming to the Boeing 747 fleet is an “experiment” using his words. I interpret that as in part to test its success before rolling it out fleetwide and otherwise since the 747 fleet is scheduled to be retired by 2016. It’s a good way to appease economy class with some sort of AVOD in the meantime. He also jokingly said, “When (passengers’) screens break, it’ll be their problem!”
- Sadly, his only comment about Mileage Plus was, “We’ll be announcing the new loyalty program shortly.” I’m hoping we’ll get the details by month-end.
- He acknowledged the slowness of the airport check-in kiosks today and claimed it was due to the strain the system is under toggling between Apollo (United) and Shares (Continental). Once the full transition to Shares is made (expected first quarter 2012) he promised faster processing. He hinted that ancillary sales might have taken a hit with the current sluggishness.
- During the Q&A he didn’t have specific percentage amounts when asked to breakdown the capacity forecast for 2012, leading me to believe they don’t really have a hard number domestic vs. international and said “flat” just to appease investors.
- When asked about the importance of fleet commonality he insisted United’s scale of operations could fully support a Boeing/Airbus mix and said it would remain so “for a very long time.”
- While he claims United’s 757s have many more years ahead of them, he did acknowledge the need to find a replacement and they’re in talks with Boeing and Airbus, as is the rest of the industry.
- Finally, a question was asked about the status of the European Union’s emissions trading scheme (ETS) where beginning January 1, 2012, all airlines flying to Europe will have to report their emissions of carbon dioxide and face fees if they go above specified caps. American, United and Continental have sued to avoid inclusion in this “tax,” as some are calling it, so this will be interesting to monitor. Are we going to see fuel surcharges and a new CO2 tax when flying to Europe next year?
If you’d like to view the slides and listen to the full presentation including the Q&A session, here’s the link to United’s Investor Relations.
Posted by Darren |
Tags: apollo vs. shares, deutsche bank, deutsche bank airline equity conference, jeff smisek, united airlines, united airlines presentation
Just released, United Airlines announces they will invest more than a half-billion dollars for cabin enhancements fleetwide. Here’s the shortlist of improvements:

According to CEO Jeff Smisek:

Additional items to note and questions that remain:
- The release states United will add flatbed seats to, “14 United 767-300 aircraft.” This sounds like they’ll convert some of the “ghetto bird” domestic 767s to premium cabin international configurations, since all current international 767s have flatbed seats.
- Channel 9 air traffic control communications will come to Continental’s 767-400 aircraft, and eventually be found on 300 Continental aircraft.
- Conversions of the remaining unmodified 777 aircraft are continuing with more than a dozen slated to be completed this year.
- Economy Plus will be seen on Continental aircraft beginning this fall with 38 birds planned to be finished by year-end. Another 100 will be converted by the end of the first quarter of 2012.
- Overhead space will be nearly doubled on Airbus A319 and A320 aircraft with newly designed compartments. This will begin in March 2012.
- Streaming in-flight entertainment and Wi-Fi will come to the 747 fleet, enabling access to video options on our mobile devices. It is unknown if this will include internet access, but I’d have to think so.
- The premium service fleet (JFK-LAX/SFO) will be overhauled beginning next year by installing flatbed seats, power ports at every row, on-demand audio and video and Wi-Fi service. The configuration of these aircraft will change to include 26 seats in Business (or maybe they’ll brand it BusinessFirst as a true First Class cabin will vanish), and 114 seats in Economy, including Economy Plus.
Posted by Darren |
Tags: Continental Airlines, economy plus, jeff smisek, united airlines
As I mentioned yesterday, I was incredibly fortunate to have been invited to Tom Stuker’s 10 million mile celebration at United’s Red Carpet Club in Chicago on Saturday. Tom is active on Flyertalk and had extended invites to 20 people for the event, so since I had already had plans to be flying through Chicago that day I jumped on the offer and received what I consider to be a unique opportunity to witness history in the making.
After landing at about noon, I visited the C-concourse Red Carpet Club where Tom’s event was to be held. Staffers had already cordoned off the dedicated area and I was excited to be among the first to see the venue for what would become an incredible occasion. I was happy to have met in person Randy Petersen, the founder of BoardingArea, Flyertalk and MilePoint, and later had the pleasure of introducing myself to Jeff Smisek, United’s CEO. My conversation with Jeff was brief and pleasant, and I told him I was “just a 1K” who was happy to be in attendance and that I looked forward to the evening at hand. He thanked me for my business and also expressed his excitement for Tom’s arrival.
I also had the privilege of meeting several devoted Flyertalkers, David Parker Brown of Airline Reporter, Dann Webb another BoardingArea blogger, Francis Gallagher publisher & CEO of Global Traveler magazine, and one of my loyal readers of this blog. Excitement was building and I recorded the following preparations underway:
Tom’s flight from Los Angeles arrived about an hour late due to the fact the inbound aircraft experienced a tire blowout on arrival at LAX, so United subbed in another 757 for UA942. Here was his arrival to the Red Carpet Club and introductory speeches by United executives:
Then it was time to hear from Tom himself. His heartfelt and sincere acceptance of his status was genuine, moving and greatly received by everyone in attendance. United went all out, too, catering an incredible buffet of food and an open bar with truly premium first class liquor and champagne.
Tom has flown 5,962 flights with United averaging 29,762 miles per month. I consider my 16+ trips to Australia as impressive, but Tom has been there more than 200 times along with 70 trips to Hawaii and countless others deserving of his Global Services status with United. He’s flown more miles than the Atlantis space shuttle has logged at the equivalent of 20 times that of a roundtrip to the Moon. My hats off to you, Tom, and may your travels continue to be smooth and rewarding. Congratulations!
Posted by Darren |
Tags: 10 million miles, chicago o'hare airport, first class, frequent flyer, jeff smisek, thomas stuker, tom stuker, united airlines
I was extraordinarily fortunate to have been in Chicago yesterday and received an invitation to attend Tom Stuker’s celebration at the C-concourse Red Carpet Club commemorating his 10 millionth mile flown on United Airlines. I met so many wonderful people, including Randy Petersen, BoardingArea’s founder and respected frequent flyer program guru, Jeff Smisek, United’s CEO, and a slew of other bloggers, industry executives, Flyertalkers, and one long-time reader of Frequently Flying.
I have several videos to post tomorrow with speeches by United executives, and of course the man of the hour Tom. For now, here’s a photo summary of the event.
Posted by Darren |
Tags: 10 million miles, jeff smisek, randy petersen, thomas stuker, tom stuker, united airlines
Last week I posted about the possibility of United being close to announcing whether or not International First Class would remain on the carrier. Yesterday a report surfaced on Bloomberg quoting United Airlines CEO Jeff Smisek saying “There are certain markets in which (first class) makes a lot of sense and there are others where it doesn’t.” There hasn’t been an official press release or updates to United’s website, but this may be good news for many high value international flyers accustomed to a three-cabin aircraft.
I read the Bloomberg article as a teaser of sorts with a lot of vague and unspecific data points. Another such point by Chief Revenue Officer Jim Compton stated “we have United 747s that have gone through a real recent reconfiguration with flat-bed in both first and business. So we’ll have both.” Retirement of the 747 fleet is scheduled for around the 2016 timeframe, and since they’ve taken down the conversion schedule for what remains on their 777 workhorse internationally, I’m led to believe this is a short-term (five year) decision. Is United considering making some of the unconverted international 777s into two-cabin aircraft?
Fleet integration is definitely a logistical challenge when merging carriers, and it sounds like we’ll have fairly different lie-flat products based on which “metal” we fly and to which markets. Continental’s seat architecture is different than United’s, and it sounds like the new United will maintain both for at least this short-term period. What United will certainly have to ensure during this period is that no market selling first class ends up with an ex-Continental metal aircraft with only two classes. Jeff Smisek acknowledges this issue in the article, however.
One good thing for frequent flyers is although United’s soft product (service & meals) in International First Class is completely inferior to that of its competitors, award redemption opportunities have been easier for the front cabin to popular destinations in Australia, Asia and Europe than that of business class. I will still generally redeem my miles for Star Alliance carriers, though, unless United really makes marketed improvements and reports begin to surface lauding a transformation. Time will paint the picture.
I am still anxious to see United’s official release to support this article, but I now expect United to keep a three-class presence in most markets served by the old United today, at least for the next five years. I now anticipate during the 2015-2016 timeframe United will make a decision on a uniform international offering (seat architecture & cabin configuration) to roll out in the 2018-2020 period based on market demand and global economic factors at that time.
Posted by Darren |
Tags: 747, 777, award redemption, boeing 747, Boeing 777, business class, Continental Airlines, first class, international service, jeff smisek, united airlines
On Tuesday, Jeff Smisek, CEO of United Airlines, made an appearance at the Stanford Graduate School of Business as the speaker for the school’s “View from the Top” lecture series. The aim of the student-run program is to bring leaders of business and social sectors in to impart wisdom on the student body, particularly focusing on their leadership style, vision and strategies for success.
I have to say, having heard Jeff now a few times, he’s a rather engaging speaker and does a fantastic job breaking down an incredibly complex industry. Here are my notes from the video presentation embedded below.
- He opened by differentiating his “talk” as he called it from a “lecture,” where the latter is done by someone smart imparting learning. He claims since he’s an executive in the airline business, by definition he’s not smart, as it hasn’t earned an adequate return on invested capital since the Wright Brothers.
- To the audience: “I want you all to fly us & always book at the last minute and pay the highest fare”. In context, it was a pretty humorous moment and not at all as it might sound to you reading it.
- Regarding the low barriers to entry to the industry, he claims, “any idiot can get an operating certificate, and many do.” He also mentioned the high barriers to exit, namely the reliance of so many manufacturers, suppliers, cities that have a vested interest in an airline surviving.
- On Air Traffic Control, he humorously said, “The ATC system is quite antiquated… it’s safe, but very very slow. It uses the finest 1950s ground based radar technology that money can buy.” Investment in that system is critical.
- The airline industry is unique in being subjected to major external events that are difficult to plan for, namely volcano eruptions (the ash cloud impacting Europe), SARS, and the earthquake in Japan.
- Regarding fuel, he claims United could buy an Airbus A380 every week and “throw it away” for the price of what the carrier spends on fuel, currently about $136/barrel, but not at the 2008 peak of $172/barrel.
- Fare increases and aligning capacity to reduced demand has been fairly successful in the current fuel situation.
- On unions, he said the situation is very difficult merging both carriers with representation differences among the work groups, as well as differences in culture. He’s working to ensure co-workers think of themselves as employees of the enterprise first, and union members second.
- Having a large loyalty base among frequent flyers provides ability to sell Mileage Plus miles to third parties, such as Chase, among other things.
- The new United is using a strategic plan template from the Continental Airlines playbook used at that carrier for the past 16 years. Namely, everything they want to do is on a single sheet of paper under the four categories of Marketing, Financial, Operating, and People.
- It’s important that everyone in the company knows the plan, only works on tasks to achieve the plan, and is given the tools to make it happen.
- Hiring talented people is paramount, and his active engagement with all work groups is critical to know exactly what’s going on at all levels.
- An open, honest approach with employees is best, specifically mentioning that if he is presented an idea from a co-worker that he knows the airline will never implement, answering “No, we’re not going to do that and here’s why…” is better than lying and saying he’ll take it under consideration.
He closed the discussion by reminding everyone to follow their passion. Money is important, yes, but a career and job you enjoy in which you can be yourself is the key to a successful life. Again, he’s a talented speaker in my opinion, and comes across as an incredibly approachable top executive.
Posted by Darren |
Tags: Continental Airlines, jeff smisek, stanford university, united airlines
Since I volunteered my seat on United Airlines this morning and scored another $400 in vouchers, I have a bit of time to recap additional news items from the week.
- Boeing 747-8 Intercontinental. The longest passenger aircraft in the world took its maiden flight this past Sunday. As I previously posted, only Lufthansa and Korean Air have orders in for the passenger version, so opportunities are at a minimum to fly on the fourth-generation ‘Queen of the Skies’. The Airline Reporter provides an excellent summary of the event, and links to additional stories, videos and posts.
- Chase Debit rewards ending at United & Continental. Effective July 12, 2011, holders (including myself) of Chase co-branded debit cards with United Airlines or Continental Airlines will no longer earn miles when using their cards. And beginning April 1st, you lose the “first checked bag free” benefit. Chase & other banks issuing Visa and MasterCard debit cards are a bit upset the fees they collect on the cards will be slashed courtesy of the Durbin Amendment. As a result, we lose the incentive benefits as consumers and will only now be able to earn miles with a mileage-earning credit card vs. one linked to a bank checking account.
- United Airlines mobile check-in. You can now check-in on your mobile device for worldwide United and United Express-operated flights. Don’t get too excited if you’re already overseas and want to check-in. Presently, only the following non-U.S. airports accept mobile boarding documents: Amsterdam, Brussels, Geneva, London Heathrow, Moscow, Munich, Osaka, and Zurich.
- Continental Airlines adds onboard Wi-Fi. Internet will be coming soon to Continentals’ fleet of domestic Boeing 737s and Boeing 757s that already have the DirecTV service. About 200 planes in total will receive the capability, and United has Wi-Fi available on all of the premium service p.s. aircraft on the JFK-Los Angeles and JFK-San Francisco routes, as well as one additional 757 in the standard domestic configuration. Jeff Smisek this week acknowledged how far behind United is lagging in this capacity, and mentioned it will be a priority in the future to roll it out fleet-wide.
- Hilton HHonors Grand Nights promotion. Hilton announced their second quarter promotion this week, which earns you 1,000 extra HHonors points for each night stayed between April 1 and June 30, 2011. Registration is required and the offer does not apply on certain categories, including many advance purchase rates.
- Air France & Airbus search for wreckage. A new search is underway for Air France flight 447 which crashed into the Atlantic Ocean on June 1, 2009. The flight took off from Rio de Janeiro bound for Paris, but was never heard from after a series of automated radio messages were sent notifying the airline of numerous problems and warning indications. Pieces of the downed Airbus A330-200 were recovered from the ocean, but this new operation hopes to recover the flight data recorders and other debris.
Posted by Darren |
Tags: 747-8, air france, airbus, airbus a330, boeing 747-8, chase debit card, Continental Airlines, hilton hhonors, Hilton Hotels, jeff smisek, united airlines
Yesterday at the JP Morgan Aviation, Transportation & Defense Conference in New York, Jeff Smisek gave a presentation on the status of United Airlines, the merger with Continental, and the future of the industry. A lot of it was high-level CEO talking points about the carrier and the future, but he did reveal a couple of interesting tidbits during his speech and afterwards in the Q&A session. Matthew provides an excellent summary over at his blog, and includes links to the audio and presentation slides. In addition to his notes, here are a few of my own:
- Consolidation. Jeff began the talk speaking about the fragmentation of the industry & mentioned consolidation is good for the industry and hopes it will continue. I doubt that means more for United, though.
- Fuel Efficiency. Frequently throughout the talk he brought this up. The carrier today is 32% more fuel efficient on a RPM (revenue passenger mile) basis than in 1992. He also joked that the APU (auxiliary power unit used while the aircraft is at the gate and to start the engines) is “the world’s most expensive coffee maker.” Knowing how focused United was in 1993 when I interned in Flight Dispatch (EXODD), it’s amazing to hear a 32% increase in efficiency. Granted, a lot of the gas-guzzlers have since been retired from the fleet.
- Business Travelers. The slide showed 65% of the total revenue comes from business travelers, who represent probably around 40-45% of the total traffic. He also mentioned United has had tremendous success in getting corporate contracts due to their network, and that of Star Alliance. Back in 1993 I had a chance to sit in on a talk Stephen Wolf, United’s then CEO, gave to a group of pilots. At that time, I recall the figures being more in the neighborhood of 30% of the traffic generated 70% of the revenue.
- Frequent Flyer Program. He calls it spectacular and huge with more members than the citizens of France worldwide. The full 2012 program will be announced later this year, and did mention it will bring enormous value to customers, What that means remains to be seen, and he closed the topic by saying, “It’s not your grandfather’s frequent flyer program.”
- FareLock. Jeff mentioned the Continental Airlines FareLock service I blogged about previously has been a successful product. Not a huge revenue earner, but successful nonetheless. This leads me to believe it will continue at the new United.
- Technology. He admitted they’re not using the best technology platform out there for reservations and back-end processes, but they’re using the one that allows them to integrate both carriers with the least issues. He didn’t call it out by name here, but is referring to the SHARES reservations system as I also blogged about previously. After a successful integration, he then said they’d be looking at the best solution out there.
- Premium Service (p.s.) JFK-LAX/SFO. These high-yield markets with dedicated aircraft will receive “significant upgrade to the interiors,” including lie-flat seats. This has stirred a lot of speculation on the boards of FlyerTalk and MilePoint with regard to p.s. going to a two-cabin format, and a possible reduction in the amount of premium seats. Last November the SAG/AFTRA contract was revised restricting actors to flying only business class domestically (unless they have enough clout for first), so we might just see the Continental BusinessFirst model onboard the p.s. flights in the future. How many seats remains to be seen, but I would have to assume they’d dedicate more real estate to the premium cabin than the standard domestic 757 versions.
- Ancillary Fees. Jeff thinks unbundling is here to stay permanently, and United will continue to seek out ways to offer features and services with “great value and high margins.” Read that as you will, but he did at least go on record as saying United will never charge for onboard bathroom use or seatbelts!
Posted by Darren |
Tags: ancillary fees, business travelers, Continental Airlines, jeff smisek, united airlines
This week’s video is another one by yours truly summarizing the United Airlines Friends & Family event at San Francisco Airport on October 10, 2010. United was gracious enough to invite some Flyertalkers to the event, and I flew up to enjoy the day. I missed out by minutes seeing the United 747 Golden Gate Bridge flyby on Saturday, but there are tons of videos showing it out there on YouTube.
I hope this event survives the merger and is once again open to Flyertalkers next year!
Posted by Darren |
Tags: blue angels, jeff smisek, san francisco airport, SFO, united airlines, united airlines friends & family day, video