June 14, 2013
Recently, Personal Finance Digest posted a summary of American Express’ no-fee business cards (see “Amex’s no-fee business cards have some good deals for consumers“). He posted the following table that does indeed show good returns on spend from these cards:
The first thing I did after seeing this post was update my page showing “Best rewards for everyday spend.” I previously had no idea that the Amex Blue for Business card earned a 30% bonus on points each year. That makes the card a solid, middle of the pack, everyday spend card. Then, I double checked my “Best Category Bonuses” page and found that I had missed a couple of entries for the SimplyCash card, so I added those.
Next, I wondered how these cards compared to those from other banks. I searched each major bank’s website for no-fee business rewards cards that offered more than 1% returns. Many cards offer no fee the first year, but this list is limited to those cards that never have an annual fee:
- Chase Ink Cash
- Chase Ink Classic
- Citibank CitiBusiness ThankYou
- US Bank Business Cash Rewards
- Capital One Spark Select
- Capital One Spark Miles Select
There are three things I look at when comparing credit cards:
- Signup bonus
- Earnings on spend
Let’s dive into each…
Free cards often have no signup bonus at all. Of the cards we’re looking at, though, here are the ones with public signup bonuses as of June 2013:
- Amex Blue for Business: 10K Membership Rewards points
- Chase Ink Cash: 20K Ultimate Rewards points
- Chase Ink Classic: 20K Ultimate Rewards points
- Citibank CitiBusiness ThankYou: 15K ThankYou points
Clearly the Chase Ink cards have the best signup bonuses of the lot. Note that you may receive better signup bonuses through targeted mailings or by visiting a branch office.
Earnings on spend
Let’s look at the point earnings from each card:
|Amex TrueEarnings||Cash||1%||4%||2%||2% travel|
|Amex Blue for Business||MR Points||1.3X|
|Chase Ink Cash||UR Points||1X||2X||2X||5X||5X||5X landline & cable|
|Chase Ink Classic||UR Points||1X||2X||5X||5X||5X landline & cable, 2X Hotels|
|CitiBusiness ThankYou||ThankYou Points||1.03X||3X rotating categories|
|US Bank Cash Rewards Visa||Cash||1%||3%||3%||3%|
|Capital One Spark Select||Cash||1.5%|
|Capital One Spark Miles||Points||1.5X|
Note that I didn’t list 2% earnings for travel with the Amex Blue for Business card because that requires booking through the Amex travel service. You can get similar rewards from any card by going through cash back portals to book travel.
Ignoring variations in point values for a moment, we can see that different cards are best for different types of spend:
- Gas: Amex TrueEarnings 4%; Amex SimplyCash 3%
- Restaurant: Amex Lowe’s 3X; Amex TrueEarnings 2%; Chase Ink Cash 2X
- Office Supply: Amex SimplyCash 5%, Chase Ink Cash 5X, Chase Ink Classic 5X
- Cell Phone: Amex SimplyCash 5%, Chase Ink Cash 5X, Chase Ink Classic 5X
- Misc: Chase Ink Cash 5X landline & cable; Chase Ink Classic 5X landline & cable & 2X Hotels; CitiBusiness rotating categories 3%; Amex TrueEarnings 2% travel;
- All other spend: Capital One Spark Select 1.5%; Capital One Spark Miles 1.5X; Amex Blue for Business 1.3X
Best for category spend:
The Chase Ink cards have more bonus categories than any other card on the chart and earn 5X in several important categories. Even when they do not have the top earnings within a category, between them they offer at least 2X in all represented categories. Additionally, the Ink cards include landline and cable charges within their 5X categories. The Ink cards earn Ultimate Rewards points worth 1 cent per point. However, it is possible to transfer those points to a premium Ultimate Rewards card (Sapphire Preferred, Ink Plus, Ink Bold) and then transfer those points to airline and hotel programs for the chance to get much more value from those points.
If your business spends heavily on gas, though, you might do better with the Amex TrueEarnings Costco card that offers 4% cash back for gas.
Best for non-category spend:
The Capital One Spark cards offer 1.5% earnings on all spend. If cash back is your objective, then these cards are best (of the no-fee business cards). If you prefer points that can be transferred to airline programs, though, consider the Amex Blue for Business card that earns 1.3X Membership Rewards points. By itself, you wouldn’t be able to transfer points to airlines, but if you add a premium Membership Rewards card to your account (personal or business), your points will be upgraded to those that can be transferred.
Credit card perks
As far as I can tell, all of the evaluated cards offer various degrees of the basics:
- Extended warranty
- Fraud protection
- Travel insurance
- Car rental insurance
Here are some areas where they differ:
- The Chase Ink cards offer primary rental collision insurance, and they offer additional savings and perks through the Ink Insider’s program.
- The Amex cards offer American Express OPEN Savings (see Business card benefits). The OPEN Savings program offers automatic cash rebates when you use your Amex business card at various merchants (As long as you meet the criteria of each one. Check the fine print).
- The CitiBusiness ThankYou card offers a “personal business assistant” (concierge service).
- All MasterCards offer MasterCard Easy Savings (see Business card benefits). The Chase Ink cards are MasterCards. The CitiBusiness card gives you the choice of MasterCard or Visa. The Easy Savings program provides automatic cash rebates at various merchants including 1% cash back at all Fuelman network gas stations. These savings are in addition to points and cash back earned automatically with your credit card.
Overall, it appears that the Chase Ink cards offer the most in the way of extra perks.
Among the no-fee business cards, the Chase Ink cards (Ink Cash and Ink Classic) offer the best combination of sign-up bonus, category spend bonuses, and perks. If you don’t spend much within the listed categories, consider either the Capital One Spark cards that offer 1.5% everywhere, or the Amex Blue for Business which earns 1.3X everywhere plus offers decent perks and a small signup bonus.
This report focused solely on no-fee business cards. It’s important to note that there may be no-fee personal cards that offer more (such as the no-fee Fidelity Investment Rewards Amex which earns 2% cash back on all spend). Also, don’t dismiss business cards that charge a fee. Capital One, for example, offers a version of their Spark Business Card with 2% cash back for all purchases. This card comes with a $59 annual fee. If you were considering the no-fee 1.5% cash back Spark card, you would do better with the $59 card simply by spending $12,000 or more each year.