I recently received a question from Reader P who lives in Greensboro, North Carolina (GSO). He has started a new career that will have him in the air a bit, and he sought my advice on which airline and hotel programs to choose.
Reader P (Note: I’m editing several emails into one for clarity)
“I need to pick your brain about travel rewards and what you think I need to do to maximize my return. Looks like I’ll be traveling quite a bit in 2012 and I want to get the most bang for my buck. I live in Greensboro, North Carolina and will be flying quite a bit more than I have in the past, with a focus in the south, east, and west. Further, I’ve never really paid much attention to hotel programs. Which one do you think is best? Also, what do you think of the Amex Platinum Card? Should I upgrade my Amex to Platinum?”
MJonTravel Responds
Living where you live, either US Airways or Delta will probably be your best bet. All things being equal, I’d rather fly Delta than US Airways, but all things aren’t equal. If you fly Delta, you have to go to Altanta. If you fly US, you have to go through Charlotte (or Philadelphia)….OR you can get in your car and drive to Charlotte if you need to. Either airline can fly you up and down the east coast, and to the west when you need to head that way.
As for the miles, in my opinion, US miles are better than Delta miles IF you intend to redeem your miles for international travel. If you are mainly going to redeem for domestic flights, then Delta will work just as well. US Airways is part of the Star Alliance, and that’s a better alliance than Delta’s SkyTeam. In either case, it’s always best to pick one airline mileage program and try to fly that one airline (or one of their alliance partners) as much as you possibly can. Not only will you build miles, you’ll be building “elite” miles and segments towards earning elite status…..and that’s what you want.
For hotels, if I ruled the world, I would only stay at Starwood hotels. But since I don’t, either Hilton HHonors or Marriott Rewards will probably serve you better. It’s a little easier to get to mid tier elite status with Hilton….16 stays or 28 nights will get you to Gold….. making you eligible for room upgrades, and best of all, they give you free internet at all their hotels if you have Gold status. I’m always torn between Marriott and HIlton….on the whole, I like Marriott hotels better….but it can be more difficult to achieve and maintain elite status with them. Starwood’s points program is the best. The SPG Card from Amex is one of the most popular cards out there. SPG points transfer 1 to 1 to most airline programs including American AAdvantage and US Airways Dividend Miles. The good thing about Marriott or Hilton is…that usually…no matter where you are going, they have some kind of hotel….whether it’s a Courtyard or a Fairfield Inn….or a Hampton Inn or Hilton Garden Inn with Hilton. With Starwood, they mainly have properties in your big cities in the US and around the world. Whichever you go with, my advice is the same, pick one program and stay in their hotels as much as possible. You want elite status.
I am a big fan of the Amex Platinum Card. It is not cheap, but if you get the business version, you might be able to write off the annual fee as a business expense? (Note: I’m not a tax professional, and the deductibility of business card annual fees is something you should consult your tax professional about.) It will get you into the airport lounges of US Airways, Delta, and American on the day of travel. Just hand them your card and a boarding pass for your flight. Heck, US Airways will even admit you with it whether you are flying them that day or not. US also happens to have a lounge in Greensboro. Between the lounge access and the Amex Cruise Privileges program, the card pays for itself as far as I’m concerned. You can read a few of my thoughts on Platinum here.
So….. Delta or US Airways, pick one and fly as much as you can with that program. If you decide to go US, you need to read this link and sign up for their Trial Preferred program. I don’t know if US flies to Colorado Springs (which I understand could be a frequent destination for you) or not. It might be cheaper to fly into DEN and drive down? Don’t know. If you wind up on United, you can credit your flight to your US Airways program and earn miles and elite miles/segments too!
What do you think of my advice to this reader? Are there other options that I’m not considering? Comment to the blog if you’d like to share your thoughts.