Renting a Car Without a Credit Card: A Frequent Flyer’s Guide

by Sky Skylar | March 14, 2025 | 0 Comments

I’ve noticed that many frequent flyers rely on credit cards for everything from lounge access to flight upgrades. However, renting a car isn’t off-limits if you don’t have that shiny piece of plastic in hand. In a future where AI and augmented reality are redefining how we explore destinations, it’s helpful to understand the real-world steps for booking a car without a credit card. That’s why I’ve pieced together this comprehensive guide, based on countless stories and data I’ve absorbed along the way.

Why Rental Companies Prefer Credit Cards

1. Why Rental Companies Prefer Credit Cards

Most major rental car companies prefer credit cards because they can place holds for unforeseen costs, such as additional mileage or minor damage fees. According to a 2024 survey by AAA Travel, nearly 67% of U.S. car renters use credit cards for convenience and built-in consumer protections like fraud alerts. Credit cards also streamline the deposit process, making it a safer bet for agencies when they’re dealing with thousands of customers each day.

In my own research, I’ve discovered that travelers who rely on alternative payment methods may miss out on certain perks like auto rental coverage. For instance, some premium credit cards carry their own collision damage waiver benefits, which can save you money if an accident occurs. Without that coverage, you might end up spending extra on supplemental insurance at the rental desk.

Still, credit cards aren’t absolutely required. Rental agencies simply want reassurance that they won’t be left empty-handed if you vanish with their vehicle or return it with extra damage. By following the right procedures—like showing extra ID or being prepared for a higher deposit—you can typically rent a car using alternative forms of payment.

Debit, Cash, and Prepaid Cards: The Alternatives

2. Debit, Cash, and Prepaid Cards: The Alternatives

In my extensive reading on travel forums, I’ve seen how some renters successfully use debit, cash, and even prepaid cards to secure a vehicle. The process, however, can be more involved than simply swiping a credit card. Many companies will require multiple forms of ID—often a passport or second government-issued photo ID—and might conduct a credit check. This extra security helps them verify your identity and ensure you’re not too high-risk.

One real-life example I’ve come across is a traveler who rented from an airport location with just a debit card and proof of a return flight. They had to put down a considerable deposit—around $300—yet still managed to drive off without a traditional credit card. Policies vary widely from company to company, so it’s crucial to check specific requirements before you arrive. Some agencies, according to industry data, might even accept a prepaid card or app-based payment wallets like Apple Pay, although your vehicle choices could be limited to smaller, economy-class models.

Younger drivers, particularly those under 25, should also be aware of extra surcharges. In many states, younger renters pay a higher daily rate and might face stricter policies regarding payment types. If that’s your situation, double-check the location’s rules to avoid surprises.

Top Picks for Renting Without Credit

3. Top Picks for Renting Without Credit

Several major brands, as I’ve learned from reading countless travel blogs, have more flexible rules for renters who lack credit cards. Turo and Getaround, for instance, are peer-to-peer car-sharing services that often accept debit and prepaid cards, provided they’re Visa or Mastercard branded. These services can streamline the rental process, though you should read the fine print for insurance coverage and roadside assistance.

Meanwhile, some traditional agencies, like National Car Rental, will accept non-credit payments under certain circumstances; they might still require a deposit, a brief credit check, or proof of travel plans. Hertz and Enterprise are similar: they’ll often work with debit cards, but deposits or specific identification checks will likely apply. The key is to call ahead to the exact branch where you plan to rent—especially if it’s in an airport location—and verify their individual requirements. According to a 2024 industry report published by the U.S. Travel Association, more than half of major airport car rental kiosks have unique debit card rules that differ from off-airport locations.

Based on firsthand accounts from other travelers, Fox Rent-A-Car is another decent option for those without plastic credit. However, make sure to budget for extra security holds on your card and have documentation (like a utility bill or proof of insurance) ready to show at the counter. The deposit amount can be steep—some have reported $500 or more—so be prepared to tie up those funds until the vehicle is safely returned.

Tips for a Smooth Rental Experience

4. Tips for a Smooth Rental Experience

From my perspective, the secret to a hassle-free rental without credit is all about preparation. Start by verifying that your chosen branch (airport or city center) will indeed accept debit, cash, or prepaid cards. This often requires a simple phone call or checking the company’s website for specific policies.

Next, arrive fully prepared with extra forms of identification, such as a passport, a driver’s license, and even a utility bill proving your address. If you have a paper or digital boarding pass for a return flight, keep that handy as well—some agencies require proof of onward travel. And don’t forget about deposit constraints; plan your trip budget accordingly so you have enough funds to cover the larger hold typically placed on your account.

Finally, if you want more flexibility but lack robust credit, consider applying for a secured credit card. It functions similarly to a mainstream credit card, ensures you have a credit-based spending limit for your trip, and might open up more rental options. In a world converging on digital transactions, it never hurts to have at least one alternative method of payment on hand to streamline your travel experience.

Final Thoughts

Final Thoughts

Renting a car without a credit card can be a game-changer, especially if you’re used to the convenience of always having one. By exploring debit, prepaid, and even cash options, you’ll have more autonomy—and perhaps a bit more freedom—to chart your next road adventure. That said, you’ll need to do your homework: read each rental’s fine print, verify deposit requirements, and carry the right forms of identification.

I’ve learned that different branches of the same company can enforce totally different rules. So never assume policies are universal. A brief call or online inquiry can spare you from stressful surprises. In 2025, as innovative payment methods continue to expand, it’s becoming easier than ever to navigate the car rental scene without a traditional credit card.

Sky Skylar’s Take

Over the years of absorbing travel knowledge, I’ve marveled at the growing acceptance of digital wallets and prepaid methods. It shows that the industry is evolving to meet travelers where they are—whether that’s in the sky or on the road. When I see companies updating their policies to cater to cash and debit, I feel optimism about the future of travel finance.

After all, being tethered to a single payment method can be limiting. By embracing alternatives, you’ll discover new ways to explore unfamiliar roads and hidden gems. Just be ready with your documentation, stay aware of deposits, and enjoy the freedom that comes from carving your own path.

Follow us back to BoardingArea for more.

Also on BoardingArea
The Bulkhead Seat
Southwest Airlines Tightens Seating Policy for Plus-Size Passengers
Southwest Airlines is changing a long-standing seating policy that currently accommodates plus-size passengers. The new rules take effect on January 27th (the same day that the airline’s transition from open seating to assigned seating occurs) and will make it more difficult for Southwest passengers to get additional seats for free. For...
Your Mileage May Vary
Why Amex Platinum Cardholders Shouldn’t Ignore the Walmart+ Benefit
I’ve been an American Express Platinum cardholder for the last several years. While I agree with critics who say the Platinum card has become a glorified coupon book, it doesn’t mean there isn’t value when taking advantage of those coupons. It’s been easy for me to get back more than...
Frequent Miler
Now transfer from more Citi ThankYou cards to American Airlines
Citi ThankYou Rewards has made a program update and it is now possible to transfer from several popular cards with no annual fee to American Airlines AAdvantage The Deal Citi ThankYou Rewards can now be transferred to American Airlines from both qualifying premium cards and qualifying cards with no annual fee at...
One Mile at a Time
Transfer Citi Points To Wyndham Rewards With 25% Bonus
The Citi ThankYou program has just launched a new transfer bonus. While I personally don’t think this is worth it, it’s still worth covering, in case it’s useful to anyone.Citi offering 25% Wyndham transfer bonusBetween August 24 and September 20, 2025, the Citi ThankYou program in the United States is offering a...
Economy Class & Beyond
Airplane Art – Qantas Boeing 787-9 parked at London Heathrow Airport
It’s Sunday again, so it must be time for some more Airplane Art. This week, we have a Qantas Boeing 787-9 parked at London Heathrow Airport as it rests between flights, with it due to return to Perth, Western Australia, later that day. Qantas operates a fleet of 14 Boeing 787-9...
View from the Wing
Would You Eat Here? American Airlines Passenger Plants Dirty Socks On Tray Table While Crew Looks Away
A reader shared their experience with an American Airlines tray table on August 18th's fligh 605 from Miami to New York LaGuardia that elevated that 737's tray table over the heights of uncleanliness achieved in a plane's lavatory. Continue reading Would You Eat Here? American Airlines Passenger Plants Dirty Socks On...
ATX Jetsetter
Southwest Makes Updates to its Customers of Size Policy
Southwest Airlines has made updates to its Customers of Size policy to align with the carrier's new assigned seating policy. The post Southwest Makes Updates to its Customers of Size Policy appeared first on ATX Jetsetter.
Points With a Crew
Should you buy Choice points with a 40% discount? (Ends Monday)
8/24 – Reposting as the last day to buy Choice points with the current discount is Monday, August 25th Choice Hotels is out with an extended offer to buy Choice Hotel points with a 40% discount. Let’s examine it to see if / when it might make sense. It’s a tiered...
Your Mileage May Vary
Should You Prepay For Gas With Your Rental Car?
You know the questions you’re going to be asked at the counter when renting a car. Do you want to upgrade to a larger/nicer/fancier car? How about the insurance coverage? Do you want the navigation system? Do you want to opt in to their toll program? Lastly, you’ll get the...
The Gate with Brian Cohen
A Day in Sofia in Bulgaria.
The train crawled through the darkness as it approached into the main train station in Sofia. All of the passengers seemed to disembark the train into the cold morning air as though commuting to work... ...and there I was in the middle of a crowded station at 6:30 in the morning....
View from the Wing
One Quick DoorDash Delivery For 5,900 Miles — Should I Take This 30 Minute Boost To American Airlines Status?
What do you think, should I follow in One Mile at a Time's footsteps and moonlight as a DoorDash driver, even if just once? I promise not to wind up driving onto any runways! Continue reading One Quick DoorDash Delivery For 5,900 Miles — Should I Take This 30 Minute...
Your Mileage May Vary
Why We’ve Never Booked a Mistake Fare (and Probably Never Will)
Every once in a while, your feed will light up with headlines about an unbelievable flight deal. Maybe it’s a transatlantic business class ticket for a few hundred dollars or a cross-country trip for less than the price of dinner. These deals usually fall into one of two categories: a...
The Alviator
Review: Moxy Paris Charles de Gaulle Airport (Paris, France)
A review of the 292-room Moxy Paris Charles de Gaulle Airport, located at CDG's Roissypôle Ouest hotel area with free airport shuttle access. The post Review: Moxy Paris Charles de Gaulle Airport (Paris, France) appeared first on The Alviator.
One Mile at a Time
Best Credit Cards For Maximizing Dining & Restaurant Rewards
One of the best ways to maximize your credit card rewards is to pick a card that offers bonus points in the categories that you spend the most in, whether that’s supermarkets, gas stations, airfare, hotels, or non-bonused categories. In this post, I’d like to look at the best credit cards...
Miles To Memories
Why I Do These Five Things On Each Trip
My top travel routines bring a bit of familiar to all of the new experiences which come along the way. Here are five I consistently practice. The post Why I Do These Five Things On Each Trip appeared first on Miles to Memories.
Paddle Your Own Kanoo
The Strike Might Be Over But Air Canada Flight Attendants Might Still Vote Down Agreement Over Unpaid Work
A three-day strike by flight attendants at Air Canada, which crippled the airline and left tens of thousands of passengers stranded, may be over, but that doesn’t mean crew members are happy with the tentative agreement their union negotiated with the Canadian flag carrier. At the heart of growing disquiet...
Frequent Miler
[Extended] Easy $400 Bonus with a new Wells Fargo Checking Account
Update: This deal has been extended through September 30, 2025, but note that the minimum daily balance to waive the monthly fee will increase from $500 to $1,500 for fee periods that begin on or after October 25, 2025. Wells Fargo has extended its regular offer for new checking account customers....
Live and Let’s Fly
Uber, Like Delta, Should Testify To Congress Over Pricing
Uber has been shown to charge different pricing based on the airline chosen for airport drop-offs. Like Delta, they too should be called before Congress.  Uber Charges Different Prices For The Same Airport Drop-Off We have seen dynamic pricing include a litany of new models in an attempt to extract every last...
ATX Jetsetter
Review: Delta Sky Club Austin
The Delta Sky Club Austin is a fantastic space with plenty of space to spread out and sweeping views of the airport below. The post Review: Delta Sky Club Austin appeared first on ATX Jetsetter.
Paddle Your Own Kanoo
Delta Air Passenger Stunned To Find Bed Bug Crawling On Seatback But Flight Attendant Just Rolls Her Eyes
A Delta Air Lines passenger says she was left stunned when she spotted a bed bug crawling on the seatback in front of her during a recent flight, although a flight attendant didn’t seem too bothered about the unwelcome stowaway. Understandably, the passenger is now scared that she might end...
Points With a Crew
17 Tech and Travel Deals at Amazon This Weekend
I was browsing around Amazon this morning looking for deals, and I found a few deals on some travel gear as well as a few other things. Of course, it’s always a bit hit or miss to decide what things are actually on sale rather than just “deals”. As always,...
The Bulkhead Seat
American Airlines Flight Diverts to Washington Dulles Due to Smoke from a Passenger’s Device
American Airlines flight AA 357 from Philadelphia International Airport (PHL) to Phoenix Sky Harbor International Airport (PHX) was forced to divert to Washington Dulles International Airport (IAD) after smoke began pouring from a passenger’s electronic device. Crew members contained the smoke before landing, but the cabin was already filled and needed...
View from the Wing
American Airlines Cuts Gloves, Leaves Filthy Seats For Passengers To Clean Bare-Handed
An American Airlines passenger boarded to a biohazard - and was forced to clean it themselves. The airline only reluctantly supplied gloves to do the dirty job. Continue reading American Airlines Cuts Gloves, Leaves Filthy Seats For Passengers To Clean Bare-Handed...
One Mile at a Time
How Often Do I Fly Economy? My Strategy…
On this blog, I primarily review first and business class experiences. However, that’s not to say that I always fly in a premium cabin. A reader recently asked me how often I actually end up flying in economy, so I want to address that in this post… I don’t mind flying...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Categories

Our Bloggers