Backpack Or Personal Item? 5 Tips You Need Now

by Brad Lightall | June 4, 2025 | 0 Comments

Every time I plan a flight, I find myself double-checking whether my backpack will count as a personal item—or if I need to budget extra for overhead bin space. In my experience, it usually hinges on meeting certain dimensions, understanding those often-overlooked airline guidelines, and doing a bit of strategic packing in advance. A recent survey by the Global Travel Council in 2024 mentioned that nearly 40% of travelers end up paying unexpected baggage fees, so the stakes are high if you get it wrong.

1. What Defines a Personal Item?

1. What Defines a Personal Item?

From what I’ve seen, most airlines consider any bag that fits under the seat in front of you to be a personal item—typically around 18×14×8 inches. In my own travels, I’ve noticed that these strict dimensions aren’t just arbitrary numbers; they’re often linked to safety regulations and comfort standards. If your backpack exceeds these measurements, it’s more likely to be classified as a carry-on, which may involve an additional fee if you’re booked under a basic economy fare.

For example, I once flew on a short domestic route only to discover that my slightly overstuffed backpack could no longer slide under the seat. I ended up having to gate-check it at the last minute, which was both a hassle and a potential risk for sensitive electronics. So I always recommend measuring your bag when it’s completely packed—especially if you cram extra souvenirs or gadgets into it—to ensure you’re still within the acceptable limits.

According to industry data from 2023, 35% of travelers bring backpacks as their primary personal item. If you’re in that camp (like me), be mindful of the airline’s specific rules, which vary more than one might think.

2. Airline Policy Variations

2. Airline Policy Variations

Policies change all the time. Major full-service airlines—think Delta, United, or American—often permit larger personal items as long as they fit under the seat without obstructing your comfort or that of fellow passengers. However, I’ve also flown on budget carriers—like Frontier or Spirit—that enforce strict dimension guidelines to a T. I recall one instance when a passenger ahead of me was asked to pop their backpack into the baggage sizer. It fit, but just barely. Had it not, they would have been charged an extra fee on the spot.

Beyond size, certain airlines have different definitions of what counts as a ‘small personal item.’ While most will allow you to stash laptops or cameras in these items, others may require you to designate your laptop bag as your sole personal item. I usually advise checking the official airline website for the most current baggage policies, especially if you’re traveling internationally. Some carriers have separate rules for different regions, which can catch you off-guard if you aren’t prepared.

I’ve also read about carriers that may update their policies seasonally or after industry changes. Inspecting airline updates before you fly is the best way to avoid any day-of-travel surprises.

3. The Difference Between Budget and Full-Service Carriers

3. The Difference Between Budget and Full-Service Carriers

Budget carriers are often the trickiest when it comes to baggage. They tend to charge for nearly everything beyond one small personal item. In my experience, if you’re keen on saving big, you need to plan carefully. That typically means investing in an ultra-compact backpack or using vacuum-seal packing cubes so your bag still meets the airline’s personal item dimensions. I once traveled on a budget airline while wearing my heaviest items—like sneakers and a jacket—to lighten my pack. Not the most convenient in hot weather, but it kept me under the size limit.

Full-service airlines, by contrast, usually include at least one carry-on and one personal item for free. However, the perks don’t stop there. With larger overhead bin allowances, you can pack that extra pair of shoes or a thicker laptop sleeve. While these carriers tend to cost more upfront, there’s potential to save on baggage fees in the long run—particularly if you travel multiple times a year. According to a 2025 industry analysis, frequent flyers on full-service carriers saved an average of $75 in baggage fees per round-trip flight compared to those flying budget airlines multiple times in the same year.

When deciding which ticket or airline approach is best, do the math. Sometimes, a slight increase in your base fare can offset the hassle and cost of additional fees.

4. Smart Packing Tips

4. Smart Packing Tips

I’m a firm believer in packing methodically for any flight. If your goal is to pass your backpack off as a personal item, the first step is to avoid overstuffing. Sure, it’s tempting to cram in that extra sweater or new book, but if it disrupts your backpack’s slim profile, you could run into trouble. I’ve found that focusing on multi-purpose items—like shoes that work for both casual and semi-dressy events—helps keep total volume down.

Next, consider the TSA: If you’re traveling with liquids, I’ve observed how pre-check lines move faster when you can easily remove your toiletry bag. Storing liquids, electronics, and other high-security-awareness items near the top of your backpack is a small step that can greatly speed up screening. According to a Transportation Security Administration report from 2024, travelers who placed devices in an accessible compartment saved an average of 30% time at security checkpoints.

When it comes to electronics, I recommend storing them flat and close to your back to keep the weight balanced. This not only saves you from extra chiropractor visits, but also helps your bag maintain a sleek shape. Thicker laptops placed right in the middle can make a normally compact backpack bulge, leading to issues when trying to stow it under the seat.

5. Selecting the Right Backpack

5. Selecting the Right Backpack

Sometimes, all the packing tips in the world won’t help if your backpack is simply too large to qualify as a personal item. For frequent travelers flying basic economy, an investment in a backpack specifically designed with airline dimensions in mind is one of the best decisions you can make. After trial and error, I settled on a model that stands around 17 inches tall and 12 inches wide—just enough for my tablet, a change of clothes, and some necessities. It has served me well on short-haul trips, saving me from last-minute headaches and baggage charges.

If you’re traveling with valuables—like cameras, passports, or essential work documents—it’s often safest to keep them in your personal item instead of your larger carry-on. I once had my carry-on bag gate-checked due to lack of overhead bin space, and it was a relief knowing my laptop and cameras were still under my seat. Even if your larger bag goes into the hold, your personal item always remains with you, giving you peace of mind. Keep an eye out for sales; I’ve seen up to 10% off promotions from reputable backpack brands, which can make a big difference if you’re planning to travel multiple times a year.

Finally, read product reviews or check travel forums before making a purchase. Other travelers often share which backpacks airlines accept without fuss, saving you from potential surprises at the gate.

Final Thoughts

Final Thoughts

Navigating airline baggage rules doesn’t have to be a guessing game. With a little preparation—measuring your backpack, checking specific airline guidelines, and refining your packing strategy—you can breeze through the boarding process without those frustrating last-minute fees. As years of travel have taught me, knowledge truly is power when it comes to baggage, so it pays to stay updated on ever-evolving airline policies.

Remember, being mindful of other passengers’ space and comfort also goes a long way. Nobody likes having to wrestle with an oversized backpack—especially not the flight attendant tasked with making the final call. By adhering to current dimensions and smart travel tips, you’ll help maintain a hassle-free experience for everyone on board.

Brad Lightall’s Take

From my perspective, your backpack can be your best friend or your worst enemy when traveling. If you treat it like an organized extension of yourself, it will never lead you astray. Overstuff it or ignore dimension rules, and you’ll quickly discover airline policies are more rigid than you’d hope.

That’s why I’m a true believer in the idea that less is more. Traveling light ensures you’re mobile, flexible, and ready for the unexpected. After all, the goal is to roam freely—backpack in tow—without being bogged down by extra baggage fees or stress.

Check out more travel tips and insights with us at BoardingArea for more.

Also on BoardingArea
One Mile at a Time
Venture X Business Card: 11 Reasons To Apply (With Up To 350K Miles)
While I’ve written a detailed review of the Capital One Venture X Business, in this post I want to share 11 reasons that this business card should be in your wallet, especially with the welcome offer currently available. While the $395 annual fee might sound high at first, the perks...
The Gate with Brian Cohen
Go On a Desert Safari
Racing over endless sand with the engine whining at full throttle, the all-terrain vehicle which I commandeered hungrily gobbled up kilometer after kilometer of flat but rutted sand while I sped across part of the open Sahara Desert; and my thumb turned yellow as it kept pressing the lever to...
Frequent Miler
How to Find & Book Emirates First Class with Miles (Video)
Emirates’ first class is arguably one of the most lavish and opulent first class experiences out there. Sadly, you can now no longer book with Emirates first class with miles unless you have elite status. Luckily, you can still use some parter miles to book Emirates first class. In this...
Live and Let’s Fly
No, You Weren’t Denied Boarding For Being Jewish. You Were Just Late.
I’m just going to come out and say it here: no, a family was denied boarding on American Airlines because they were Jewish. Shame on this family for–who arrived late to the gate–for trying to blame their tardiness on antisemitism, a very serious and unfounded charge. Rude American Airlines Passenger...
ATX Jetsetter
Weekly Recap: June 7, 2025
Catch up on the latest aviation and travel related news for the week ending June 7, 2025 in the ATX Jetsetter weekly recap. The post Weekly Recap: June 7, 2025 appeared first on ATX Jetsetter.
Point Me to the Plane
Tokyo’s Mexican Oasis: A Guide to Flavorful Escape
Mexican food in Tokyo? Sí, por favor! Here are 6 must-try places.
Your Mileage May Vary
The Worst Way to Use Hyatt Points? It Might Be in Vegas
I used to think it was nearly impossible to make a *bad* Hyatt redemption. After all, I’ve routinely gotten 2 to 4 cents per point—like the time we booked a…
An unknown error occurred.
BoardingArea
7 Reasons to Achieve Hyatt Globalist Status for Travelers
Hyatt Globalist status, the highest tier in the World of Hyatt loyalty program, remains a standout for travelers who want an elevated hotel experience. By harnessing flexible qualification paths, this tier provides a robust collection of perks—from waived resort fees to priceless suite upgrades—that can transform any stay into a...
View from the Wing
This Family Reached The Gate While Their Plane Was Still Boarding—But American Airlines Software Gave Their Seats To Someone Else
This is terrible customer service. The family could have made the flight, despite their American Airlines delay. They rushed to the gate, found the flight still boarding, and were relieved - only to have that taken away from them because (1) their seats had already been given away...
One Mile at a Time
IHG One Rewards Premier Credit Card Review: Great Benefits, Low Fee
Hotel credit cards are incredibly underrated. Even if you don’t spend much money on them, they can offer huge perks, including elite status and free night certificates. When you combine these two factors, a lot of these cards offer outsized value.
Frequent Flyer Bonuses
IHG One Rewards: Receive up to a 100% bonus when buying points
IHG One Rewards members can earn up to a 100% bonus with the hotel program’s latest sale for buying points that runs until June 13, 2025. With a 100% bonus you can buy 200,000 points and receive 400,000 in total with bonus which will cost US$2,000.  This means each point...
The Bulkhead Seat
Delta Adds Two Routes for Holiday Skiing and Beach Time
Delta Air Lines added two seasonal routes to run through the holidays this year.… The post Delta Adds Two Routes for Holiday Skiing and Beach Time appeared first on The Bulkhead Seat.
Live and Let’s Fly
Trump Executive Order Lifts Ban On Supersonic Flights Over USA
As US companies work on a next-generation of jets that exceed the speed of sound, President Donald Trump has signed an executive order lifting the ban on supersonic flights over United States land. Trump Lifts Ban On Supersonic Flights Over USA Via Executive Order The Executive Order, signed by Trump...
Frequent Miler
Current Hotel Promotions for June 2025
All major hotel brands dangle various carrots in front of customers to incentivize their patronage. Bonuses for for elite status, loyalty program membership and credit card spending all serve as sweeteners that make rewards-earning a little faster and more fruitful. Promotions are another significant way that hotel loyalty programs try...
View from the Wing
Southwest Passengers Learn The Hard Way: One Change Now Wrecks Their Return Flight, Losing Free Bags, Perks, And Travel Credits
You can no longer change the outbound portion of a ticket without affecting the return and this appears even to impact same day flight changes. Continue reading Southwest Passengers Learn The Hard Way: One Change Now Wrecks Their Return Flight, Losing Free Bags, Perks, And Travel Credits...
One Mile at a Time
Good: Alaska Upgrades Seattle To Seoul Incheon Flights To Boeing 787
Its an exciting time for Alaska Air Group, followingthe companys takeover of Hawaiian Airlines. Were seeing the airline totally shift its strategy, including turning Seattle-Tacoma International Airport (SEA) into a global hub, withthe goal of having 12 long haul destinations by 2030.
One Mile at a Time
Did American Deny Boarding To Family For Being Jewish? Or Just For Being Late?
There’s a video going viral of a family reportedly being denied boarding on an American flight, with the father suspecting that this only happened because they were Jewish. Is there any truth to that, or what’s really going on here?
View from the Wing
Le Meridien Maldives Hits Guests With 24-Hour Ultimatum—Marriott’s Latest Shady Move Against Mistake Rates [Roundup]
A roundup of the most important stories of the day. I keep you up to date on the most interesting writings I find on other sites – the latest news and tips. Continue reading Le Meridien Maldives Hits Guests With 24-Hour Ultimatum—Marriott’s Latest Shady Move Against Mistake Rates [Roundup]...
TravelUpdate
Amex Platinum Card $1,400 value, new points transfer bonuses, bloggers killing deals & more…
How much value can you get from the Amex Platinum Card, new transfer bonuses and more as we wrap up some stories from the week gone by.
An unknown error occurred.
BoardingArea
Unlock The Best Elite Perks With Hertz President’s Circle
Hertz President's Circle represents the top tier of Hertz's Gold Plus Rewards program and is designed for frequent flyers who want an easier, faster, and more rewarding car rental experience. President's Circle members enjoy benefits such as guaranteed vehicle availability, priority service, and free car-class upgrades, all of which can...
Eye of the Flyer
Card Benefits Ending, Cards That Offer Free Bags, Shocking NCL Video, American Airlines First Class Review, C1 Ending Perks and 750,000 Point Offer Soon Gone!
I swear, even stuck on the ground for months now, 2025 is flying by faster than any other year of my life. I mean Q2 is just about over and I have been busy, literally, eating up my quarterly Hilton credits on my four cards that offer quarterly perks. With...
Frequent Miler
It’s the most wonderful time of the year – annual challenge season begins! [Week in Review]
After spooky season, I think annual team challenge season is my favorite of the year. I haven’t invented any kind of decorative pageantry for this season yet, but I think there’s sort of a meta way in which these team challenges are an analogy for miles and points themselves. It’s...
Live and Let’s Fly
Economy Class Breakfast On Qatar Airways
Each week, my Meal of the Week feature examines an airline meal from my travels over the years. This may be a meal from earlier in the week or it may be a meal served over a decade ago. This week’s Meal of the Week explores what economy class breakfast looks like...
Live from a Lounge
Flash Sale: Get 100% bonus on IHG points purchases
A targetted IHG bonus points purchase promotion has been launched. Here are some examples of how booking hotels on points can save up to 50% on the cost of the stay. The post Flash Sale: Get 100% bonus on IHG points purchases appeared first on Live From A Lounge.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Categories

Our Bloggers