Woman Flies American Airlines From Phoenix To Pittsburgh. Then She Looks In Her Checked Bag—And Notices Something Missing: ‘Insane To Me’

by Madeleine Wagner | September 9, 2026 | 0 Comments
woman shares American airlines issue (l) American airlines (r)
@feefaleef_/Tiktok, Photo by Shutr on Unsplash

When someone steals from you, you’re left with a kind of awful emotional stew of rage and helplessness. Not only did you lose an object you own, you lose a little trust in humanity.

That’s the allegation one frequent flier is making against American Airlines. In a recent flight from Phoenix to Pittsburgh, she says that the security of her luggage was breached: Her makeup bag was stolen. And Fahimah (@feefeleef) says the airline was totally dismissive of her claim.

How Did American Airlines Handle It?

Fahimah says, “Let me make one thing  very clear, I never get online to be speaking negatively about anything.” But this is something she’s willing to make an exception for. She’s an AAdvantage member and a very specific and meticulous packer. “When I landed in Pittsburgh my make-up bag was missing from my bag. It was stolen. It was removed,” she says.

But when she sought redress, she says that the person she spoke to told her they have “no ability whatsoever” to help her.

In her video, which has been viewed 9,373 times, Fahimah says she was told to wait. She flew in on Friday, and then had to delay her conversation until Monday. On Monday, she says American Airlines told her to file a “delayed baggage claim report” in order to process the event.

Fahimah did not respond to a TikTok direct message.

Woman Disappointed In American Airlines

In her video’s caption, Fahimah says “@American Airlines DO BETTER! I’m so disappointed. This is so unlike me and I hate it but I’ve never felt so violated. Literally have travelled internationally/domestically so many times and this has neverrr happened. I know it’s just makeup but it matters to me idc!!!! I already filled a missing contents claim, but ig that’s not enough.”

She’s upset and disappointed in a company she trusted. But people were hardly surprised. Some offered solutions. Others commiserated.

Annalise suggested, “This can’t help you now but for the future, the Knog luggage lock is great. It’s super annoying to put on, but it’s super difficult to take off without it being obvious. It’s also able to be tracked via find my friends and you can set it to beep if tampered with.”

A couple of other users offer joking solutions. “I put a note in my checked luggage that says ‘I got bed bugs,'” said 42383user).

Veritas12215 recalled, “Years ago on this app I saw a girl put brown concealer on a Maxi pad and placed it at the top of her luggage. After getting robbed at Lisbon airport I get it.”

Another user agreed that American Airlines is particularly prone to this type of opportunism. “Girl American Airline is bad abt stealing like it’s forever embrassing but i literally gotten dirty panties stolen and it was the entirety of what I brought and my bag was completely repacked (they were dirty bc very end of my trip),” said blah5424.

American Airlines did not respond to an email.

Airline Makes Things Right … Enough

The video touched such a nerve that Fahimah posted two updates. In the first, she said that she was disappointed by the company’s treatment, not because of the make-up, but because of the representatives’ alleged rudeness. So in a last-ditch effort for accountability, she sent an email all the way up the corporate ladder.

“I don’t know if its the Howard [University] in me, I emailed all of their executives…we’ll see how it goes.”

Update: It went well. In her final video, Fahimah reported that American Airlines agreed to give her 10,000 miles.

How Prevalent Is Baggage Theft?

For those who are concerned about tracking and preventing airline theft, there’s no one answer. This is in part because of the nature of Transportation Security Administration security protocols, but also because people do travel with valuable things. That’s where a traveler has some control. “The best plan is to travel as light as possible—for example, I recommend everyone leaves the jewelry at home—and keep anything you can’t afford to lose on you at all times,” advised one user on the Rick Steves’ traveler forum.

Other advice includes heading straight to baggage claim once you land, because brazen thieves have tried to walk away with luggage that isn’t theirs. Another suggestion is to travel with slightly shabby-looking luggage. Thieves assess the potential score that might be in your luggage based on its appearance.

Finally, consider a TSA approved lock. The internet’s consensus seems to be that TSA has too many cameras for its agents to take anything. So chances are, the theft of things like makeup bags is happening elsewhere.

@feefaleef_ @American Airlines DO BETTER! i’m so disappointed. this is so unlike me and i hate it but i’ve never felt so violated. literally have travelled internationally/domestically so many times and this has neverrr happened. i know it’s just makeup but it matters to me idc!!!! i already filled a missing contents claim, but ig that’s not enough… #plane #traveltiktok #fypシ #airport #storytime ♬ original sound – fahimah
Also on BoardingArea
2PAXfly
WEEKLY REVIEW: Sunday, 4 October 2026
Hello travellers, Greetings from London! I’m here in the United Kingdom thanks to a bunch of credit card points transferred to Cathay Pacific before the conversion was devalued. Two flights to get here: one on an A350, and the other on a B777 with Aria Suites in Business Class. What happened...
Frequent Miler
Last Chance Deals: IHG points sale, United portal promo, Hotels.com gift card discount, & more
Welcome to our weekly list of what’s ending this week, along with a collection of other deals due to end soon. It’s a bit of a quieter week for expiring deals, but there are still several soon-to-end offers that are worth being aware of. That includes the latest IHG points...
Economy Class & Beyond
Last Week at Economy Class and Beyond – 3rd October
We’ve hit the buffers on another week, and as usual, the world is proving that there is only one constant within it – change. But it’s still Saturday, so it must be time for Last Week at Economy Class and Beyond. The Golden Boys of Birmingham ( James Watt, Matthew...
Points With a Crew
These Are The Most Unacceptable Things You Can Do On An Airplane
A recent poll ranked 37 things you can do on an airplane, from acceptable to not. Leading the way was letting children play in the aisle, followed by ...
The Gate with Brian Cohen
What Is Wrong With This Photograph? Part 373: Reader Edition
Well, it was bound to happen sooner or later: some bizarre person who founded The Gate With Brian Cohen — he has admitted to errors in the past and will remain unidentified in this article — committed a careless mistake in a graphic illustration for an article called New “Flight...
woman travelling with her husband (l) flight attendant shares flight experience (c) plane in the sky (r)
BoardingArea
Flight Attendant Walks Up To Couple. Then The Wife Begs Her To Move Her Husband To Another Seat
"Traveling with a man who is a romantic partner is EXHAUSTING."
Frequent Miler
Up to $50 off at Amazon with 125 Citi points
Amazon.com is offering up to 40% off / up to a $50 discount when using 125 Citi Thank You points (worth $1) at checkout. Note that your offer may vary — mine was only for 20% off up to $15.   The Deal Amazon is offering up to 40% for...
The Bulkhead Seat
2026 Weekly Review: October 2nd
Greetings from Chicago! I was in San Francisco for a few days this week…
Your Mileage May Vary
Hotel Parking Fees Are Getting Ridiculous. Here’s How To Avoid Them
Overnight parking can add a surprisingly large amount to the cost of a hotel stay. Fortunately, there are several ways to avoid or reduce the charge, if you plan ahead.…
Frequent Miler
Current hotel promotions for October 2026
All major hotel brands dangle various carrots in front of customers to incentivize their patronage. Bonuses for for elite status, loyalty program membership and credit card spending all serve as sweeteners that make rewards-earning a little faster and more fruitful. Promotions are another significant way that hotel loyalty programs try...
View from the Wing
American Airlines Flight Attendant Complains To Delayed Passengers—“I’ve Been Up Almost 24 Hours”
After their first plane returned to Los Angeles, Maui passengers boarded a replacement—and heard a flight attendant say he’d been awake almost 24 hours. He blamed a scheduling mix-up, while a passenger says the crew’s frustration carried into service.
woman shares travelling struggles (l) flight view (r)
BoardingArea
Woman Warns Airline About Her Nut Allergy. Then She Sees What They Start Handing Out
"I don't have to change my habits for you!"
One Mile at a Time
Weekly Review: October 03, 2026
I hope everyone is having a nice weekend so far! I’m off on a quick adventure, which should involve some fun airline reviews, a cruise review, and more. Stay tuned, and I’ll continue publishing my Japan trip report, from the journey I wrapped up a couple of weeks ago. On...
The Bulkhead Seat
Hyatt Accelerates Luxury Expansion Across Mexico and the Americas
Hyatt is closing out 2026 by expanding its luxury portfolio across Mexico, Canada, the…
Points With a Crew
Kickstarter: Smart Belt 2026 (Back By Sunday)
The Smart Belt 2026 is an Italian leather belt with 32 micro-adjustments, cut-to-size system, and a Kevlar core. It's on Kickstarter, but only for a few more ...
Your Mileage May Vary
How to Visit Jewel During a Singapore Changi Airport Layover
Singapore’s Changi Airport has plenty to keep travelers occupied during a layover. But visiting its most recognizable attraction – the Rain Vortex inside Jewel – requires a little planning. Jewel…
Frequent Miler
Hertz Amex Offer: Get $75 back when spending $350+
A new, targeted Hertz Amex Offer Is out this week: get a $75 statement credit when you spend $350 or more on rentals through mid-October. The Deal Spend $350+ on one or more rentals at Hertz Corporate-owned locations in the US & get $75 back as a statement credit with...
Miles To Memories
Up To 50% Off Amazon! Amex Membership Rewards Pay With Points Offer Is Back
There is a new 50% Off Amazon With Membership Rewards Points offer that you can check your account to see if you are targeted for it.
The Gate with Brian Cohen
Equator. Ecuador. Equinox?
The main reason why I traveled to Ecuador is for the quest to reach the equator on the equinox so that I can claim to have been in spring, summer, autumn, and winter within a split second — but things do not always work out as intended; and I cannot...
Live and Let’s Fly
Review: Qatar Airways Al Mourjan Business Lounge – The Garden Doha (DOH)
Qatar Airways’ Al Mourjan Business Lounge known as “The Garden” in Doha (DOH) is a beautiful place to spend a long layover, with extensive seating, good food, quiet rooms, and even a gym. I spent much of an eight-hour overnight connection here and enjoyed the lounge…though the service at dinner...
View from the Wing
Denver Airport Spent Over $21,000 On A Party For One Employee—$466 Per Attendee [Roundup]
Denver airport spent over $21,000 on one employee’s retirement party for just 45 people—more than $466 per attendee. Also: a Delta Diamond with 10 million SkyMiles eyes United, nearly 40% skip paying at an airport’s honor-system parking lot, and Australia’s card surcharge ban shifts the cost into advertised prices.
Your Mileage May Vary
This Simple Hotel Room Hack Gives You Extra Space When You Need It
Hotel rooms aren’t exactly overflowing with usable surfaces, especially when two people need space at the same time. Turns out there’s an easy solution hiding in many rooms. I’d like…
View from the Wing
Chase’s New $350 IHG Card Offers 200,000 Points—Plus $400 In Flight Credits Before Your First Renewal
Chase’s new $350 IHG credit card can return $400 in flight credits before your first renewal, on top of a 200,000-point initial bonus. It also gives you enough elite nights to choose a confirmable suite upgrade without first earning those nights through hotel stays.
flight on the go (l) men share travelling experience (c) London landmark (r)
BoardingArea
Brothers Board Flight To London. Then The Wheel Falls Off The Plane. Then It Gets Worse
"You're all gonna have to get off the plane."

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Categories

Our Bloggers